General Layout
I’m a bit of a UI nerd so sorry for the length of this: It is all meant in good faith!!
For reference, i have tried the UI on a 2560×1440 screen & 1920×1080 screen and my opinion of both are the same.
Color Theme;
Dark UI is fine, but:
Grey-on-black
Small font
Minimal line spacing
This really causes eye strain to be honest.
Suggestions:
Slightly increase font size or line height
Increase contrast for usernames vs message text
Consider alternating message backgrounds (very subtle)
Chat feels unintentionally spammy:
Right now:
Admin messages
System messages
Regular chat
…all look extremely similar.
kind of feels like a big wall of grey text
Fixes:
Stronger visual distinction:
Admin/system messages → boxed, tinted background
User messages → lighter contrast
Slight indentation or grouping by user
Reduce repetition (The pinned message is there! people will see it!)
I saw in another post the suggestion for the return of people altering their font color. Please don’t!
This was horrid before when people used neon colors and was unreadable in both light and dark mode. Maybe customizable username colors instead?
Members list is information-dense but low value
The members panel:
Shows usernames + ages
No status, activity, or relevance indicators
Takes up a LOT of horizontal space
After 10–15 names, it’s basically noise.
Improvement ideas:
Collapse by default
Show only:
Moderators
Recently active users
Friends / favorites
Add visual hierarchy (icons, badges, activity dots)
TL;DR
The layout isn’t bad, but it feels:
Overcrowded on the left
Underutilized on the right
Visually flat in the center
In all honesty I love that the site is going to be more modern looking than the previous iteration and can not wait for the final thing to go live. The steps you are taking are in the right direction :)
Log in to comment and vote
Comments3
MenChats Admin
Feb 11
Add option above user listing to switch between members/online/messages
MenChats Admin
Feb 11
MenChats Admin
Jan 28
@Jaxon Paige would you mind emailing to help us out? We’d love the help. support@menchats.com